Jump to navigation
Jaffe Staff
LinkedInFacebook

How to pilot new legal marketing initiatives

Call them dress rehearsals, dry runs or mock trials, legal marketers and attorneys are accustomed to practicing for important opportunities. Marketers would not advise attorneys to attend the in-person portion of an RFP process potentially worth hundreds of thousands of dollars without practicing. Good trial lawyers do not show up at the start of a trial without preparation.

Yet, when it comes to initiatives led by the marketing department, we may not take the same approach, instead giving in to the pressure to push out new initiatives quickly or to roll out new marketing projects in an effort to prove our non-billable value. 

Have you ever had a marketing initiative fail? So have I. Was it because it was a bad idea? Of course not. Was it because you just jumped right in without any planning? I didn’t think so.

More than likely, the idea had been thoroughly researched, vetted and approved by the marketing committee and/or firm management, countless hours had been spent on the strategic plan for the project, an accurate budget was in place, and necessary documentation and materials had been drawn up. The project was rolled out to the firm to a lot of fanfare.

Then, at best, a handful of attorneys actually used the new software or worked with the new business intelligence manager. At worst, the naysayers loudly questioned the need and monetary value of yet another marketing project and, perhaps, even managed to stop the project in its tracks. Or, as is often the case, after the fanfare, it was back to billable business as usual. Either way, many law firm projects labeled as marketing initiatives are not successful as a result of internal politics or firm culture.

The power of the pilot

In many industries, successful companies frequently test new or improved products or processes by rolling out a limited pilot. Piloting is a staple of marketing management in these companies and provides an understanding of the customer, as well as insight and control over budgets and resources, and delivers proven results. All of which can greatly improve the likelihood of success of the product or process. And all of which can be used to successfully implement marketing initiatives in the law firm setting.

Realistically, law firms are not likely to have the budget needed to run a pilot program for every marketing initiative. However, their use for key initiatives, especially those facing internal roadblocks, has proven successful with projects ranging from branding to rolling out a new CRM or implementing a client feedback program.

 Well-executed pilots share three components: feasibility, creditability and replicability. Internal pilots can help the legal marketer identify the internal challenges (feasibility), achieve some early buy-in (creditability), and refine the approach to or scope of the project before it is too late (replicability).

Five tips for an effective pilot

  1. Set clear objectives for the pilot and for the long-term running of the project. In the earliest phases and with some regularity, communicate the objectives to everyone in the firm who will be affected by the initiative, as well as to the pilot participants. Transparency and opportunities for input are important to gaining trust and commitment and to establishing creditability for the initiative.
  2. Thoughtfully define the pilot participants. Who will you involve? Will the pilot be geographic or practice based? Should you include a cross-section of offices and practices or roll out one practice group or one office at a time? It is important to select pilot participants who believe they have, or can be readily convinced they have, a need for the new initiative. They need to feel that participation in the pilot group is worth their time.
  3. Establish an easy and ongoing method for gathering feedback. At every step of the pilot program, invite feedback on any and all aspects of the pilot. Was the training of the appropriate level for attorneys as compared to staff? Did the training materials go into enough or too much detail? What changes could be made to any part of the process to decrease frustration, lessen the amount of non-billable time involved or increase creditability?
  4. Make necessary adjustments. With your own observations of the strengths and weaknesses of the pilot, along with the feedback from the participants, be ready to quickly implement changes. Only if you receive feedback or determine for yourself ways to improve has the pilot been successful. 
  5. Launch your final program with greater confidence. Having addressed key issues or concerns early on with a willing group of a manageable size, you are ready to more confidently roll out the initiative across the firm. Approach each new roll-out recipient group as another pilot to continually improve the internal appetite for the project.

If you would like to approach your next marketing initiative with greater confidence, use the power of the pilot.

Let us know if we can help your firm leverage pilot programs. Contact Terry M. Isner at TMIsner@jaffepr.com.

Blog Posts

Ranking the Lawyer Ranking Services
Should Attorneys Make Public Statements? Taking the Temp on Taking a Stand
Raise Your Profile and Your Revenue: 4 Keys to Attorney Business Development

Subscribe today!

Join over 10,000 people who
receive our weekly legal marketing
best practice tips and news.

SIGN UP NOW
  • About
  • Services
    • Business Development
    • Public Relations
    • Branding
    • Content Marketing
    • RankingsForLawyers®
    • Website/Digital Marketing
    • Social Media
    • Creative Services
    • Multimedia
  • Our Team
  • Our Work
    • Portfolio
    • Case Studies
  • Blog
  • Resources
    • Attorney Advertising Rules by State
    • Insights
    • News and Events
    • Policy Templates
      • Law Firm Blogging Policy Template
      • Law Firm Crisis Communications Policy Template
      • Law Firm Media Policy Template
      • Social Media Policy Template
      • Law Firm AI Policy Template
  • Contact Us
Adapt to change.

Proud Business Partner of

Connect With Us

Subscribe to our emails

Join over 10,000 people who receive weekly
legal marketing tips and news.

SIGN UP

Quick Links

Careers >
Contact Us >
Our Team >
News >
Blogs >
Insights >

Locations

Colorado
Delaware
Florida
Illinois
Massachusetts
Maryland
New Jersey
New York
North Carolina
Oklahoma
Texas
Virginia
Jaffe 1025 Connecticut Ave NW Suite 1000 Washington, DC 20036 P: 877.808.9600
Disclaimer Site Map © 2026