The modifier “social” is supposed to separate social media from other forms of marketing and PR. But the tactic’s social aspect is also the part that either prevents us from using it or from using it as the two-way communication tool it’s supposed to be.
I am guilty of the latter. I find that I push out updates like I am Ashton Kutcher and everyone is waiting to see what I eat next. Obviously, that works for Kim Kardashian and other celebrities, but for us average Joes, who really cares? We may have the sharing part down, but are we following through by listening and responding to create the experience of a conversation, instead of just making statements?
There is a handful of social media experts in the legal industry who are doing it right, spending their days creating dialogues by sharing information that fosters reactions and following up with responses. But most of what I see only goes one way. While you might be reaching your audience with good and helpful information, you aren’t fostering brand loyalty by just talking. You also need to listen and be present.
Rethinking Social Media for Lawyers
The purpose of social media is to build brand awareness and customer loyalty by connecting and communicating with your audiences. That said, everyone on social media is trying to do exactly this all the time. That makes social media a very noisy and crowded venue, so if it’s used without some mastery of the tool, your message is likely to fall on deaf ears.
I want to disclose that, from time to time, I do question the value of social media as a legal marketing tool. Lawyers and legal marketers are busy people; law firms often have minimal support staff; and marketing expenses are often viewed as overhead rather than investments that could lead to a solid return. This means that some professionals are reluctant to invest the necessary time, energy and creative thinking required to develop a successful social media initiative. In these situations, getting buy-in from your attorneys is a losing battle.
If you find yourself struggling to convince your lawyers of the value of social media, don’t force the issue. Odds are the minimal effort they’ll put forth won’t result in any significant impact.
Maybe it’s time to look at social media differently – not as a “must have,” but more as a strategic tool that you use to achieve a set of clearly defined goals. After all, it could be argued that social media is the new advertising and, like ad strategies of yesterday, there are target audiences from which the campaign is designed to inspire action. The difference between social media and advertising is that your target audiences can now talk back.
During the pre-Internet days, we spent a lot of time and money on designing ad campaigns and reviewing circulation and readership demographics. These same steps can very easily be applied to a social media campaign. What I suggest is this: Let’s not over-think the social strategy component of social media. Let’s instead try to use social media as a creative branding tool and allow the social aspect to occur organically. If you invest the time into developing a well-planned and well-executed campaign, I believe the social part will happen naturally.
Creating a Winning Social Media Campaign
There is no better example of a brand that effectively used social media to organically stir up conversation than Oreo’s Super Bowl XLVII tweet from 2013. During the game, at 8:38 p.m. to be exact, the Superdome in New Orleans experienced a sudden blackout. Identifying a prime opportunity to participate in an international conversation, Oreo’s marketing personnel immediately went into action to develop a creative campaign with the hope that social media users would make the promotion go viral. What resulted was a simple yet elegant image that the brand tweeted out from its official Twitter handle.
In the image, an Oreo cookie is framed by a spotlight and surrounded by darkness. Across the bottom of the image reads the text, “You can still dunk in the dark,” accompanied by a stylized Oreo logo.
The campaign was incredibly successful, with the image being retweeted 10,000 times in just one hour. But why was it so successful? After all, what is so innovative about an image of a cookie? The answer is a combination of creative thinking and agility.
First, Oreo’s marketers were savvy enough to recognize an opportunity when it presented itself. Twitter has become the social network of choice for individuals to participate in large-scale conversations. If something happens in the national or international media, you can bet it will have a presence on Twitter within minutes. Oreo decided to participate in the large-scale conversation of the Super Bowl blackout knowing that anyone following Super Bowl-related conversations on Twitter – a number that likely tallied in the millions – would almost certainly see the campaign.
Second, timing is everything, particularly on social media, where the churn of new content can occur within seconds. If Oreo had posted its campaign even an hour later, it would have missed the window of opportunity. Fortunately, the company had the ability to act fast. As AdAge reported, the agency behind the Oreo image gathered in a war room during the Super Bowl and designed, captioned and approved the idea within minutes.
Adapting to a Social World
As Oreo demonstrated, one size doesn’t fit all when it comes to social media. Law firms and lawyers have to take the basics and manipulate them in creative ways to achieve their goals. Not every practice or attorney is cut out for social media, and, frankly, that is OK. But there are some law firms, practices and attorneys for whom social media presents an incredible opportunity – one that could help them rise above the noise and achieve success.
I do want to make one disclaimer here regarding LinkedIn. LinkedIn is the one social network on which you should be present – although I think it is nothing more than a giant online Rolodex. But it is where people go to find information during the hiring process. So regardless of your comfort level with social media, I think being a legal professional in today’s world does necessitate creating a LinkedIn profile. To that end, when you do create your profile, I encourage everyone to present themselves honestly and strategically while also regularly updating your profile to keep your information current.
But back to using social media more creatively. To do so, I suggest we focus on those channels not used as much in the legal profession, such as Facebook, Twitter and Instagram. Although Twitter is the noisiest and most crowded social network, it can be a great tool for spreading your message, as Oreo demonstrated. However, that can only happen if you look to social media as a strategic resource and not with the “do or die” mentality that so many social media experts seem to promote.
So how can law firms take the Oreo approach to social media? After all, law firm brands are not nearly as recognizable as that of one of the country’s most beloved cookies. While social media is not suited for every firm, it does work well for practices, attorneys and boutique law firms that concentrate on specific niche areas.
Consider the example of an associate at the Chicago-based law firm of Freeborn & Peters LLP, where, a member of its Food Industry Team has implemented a creative and highly productive social media campaign. His strategy is based on several acute insights into the behavior of his target customers: fruit and vegetable farmers. The attorney sends out bankruptcy alerts to agricultural producers who need to know – and act swiftly – if one of their customers is experiencing financial distress. Using Twitter, he can reach these decision-makers via their mobile devices, even if they are tending to crops in the field. Often, their very next action is to give him a call.
But he also needs people to follow him, so he has made a practice at major agricultural trade shows to visit each display booth and to “tweet out” pictures of the major produce vendors. Of course, they respond by retweeting and following him, driving his social media audience even higher. The results of this simple, effective and rather cunning approach to social media include 10 percent year-on-year growth in his book of business.
Of course, getting visitors to view and interact with your content is just the first step. Just like any sales cycle, there’s a process. After the initial interaction on the part of your audience, it is up to you to take the next step. Follow up with a direct communication. Initiate a conversation. Directly share information that you think will be relevant to that individual’s interests. The goal is to gauge success not solely on interactions but on the quality of these interactions.
While such an immersive social media strategy won’t work for every firm, every practice or every attorney, it will work for a lot of them. So let’s rethink how we use social media. Let’s see it as the two-way communication tool it is. Let’s get better at being social.
This article originally appeared in Marketing the Law Firm in the June 2015 issue.