The perception of lawyers being shady, snarky and uncivil is as old as Father Time, and reinforced through movies, television, jokes and books – both fiction and non-fiction. Just look at Breaking Bad’s popular spin-off, Better Call Saul, in which a struggling attorney undertakes extreme, and often unscrupulous, measures just to come out on top against his opponents – whether they are a high-ranking partner at his father’s law firm or a Mexican drug lord.
Law firms have to fight the public image battle every day with constant streams of public relations, advertising, social media and marketing campaigns. But all the good deeds and pro bono works don’t mean a thing when national headlines write of spectacular fails about lawyers behaving badly.
Over the past year alone, there have been major news stories about lawyers cooking their firms’ books, creating fake vendors to invoice firms and clients for non-work to the tune of more than $5 million, and embezzling clients out of $30 million. All alleged, of course.
Then there are the less financially lucrative shenanigans that are being reported about bad lawyers in the news every day: lying, discrimination, forgery, fraud, bribery and corruption, to name but a few. Just check your local state bars for news of current attorneys being disbarred and penalized each month for their wrong choices.
How is it possible, in this day of transparency and immediate public shaming via social media, that lawyers still continue to engage in such enormous wrongdoings? The psychology behind that behavior is a topic for another day. What I do want to cover is how the actions of one or a small handful of bad attorneys can have a negative impact on a law firm’s reputation, while also inflicting collateral damage on the legal profession as a whole.
The Price of Bad Behavior
How does bad behavior, displayed in full in a public forum, affect a law firm?
It’s hard to capture something that can’t be quantified. BTI Consulting Group’s annual survey of corporate counsel finds that “big relationship flameouts and spectacular law firm failures are rare,” writes Law360, suggesting that reasons like accumulated dissatisfaction cause law firms’ and corporate counsels’ faltering relationships.
But who can quantify whether a rogue partner’s actions will cause a firm not to be named on a general counsel’s shortlist? The credibility of firms with headline-generating misdeeds sharply declines, as factors of trust and truth must be overcome.
What to Do if a Lawyer Behaves Badly
What can a law firm do when one of its attorneys is a disgrace? Talk about it, even if you don’t want to. Hold your firm to the higher standard. Each situation will warrant a different range of communication and the delivery of the messages, but here are a few more reputation management must-dos:
- Apologize – publicly and widely – and distance the firm from the wrongdoings of that attorney.
- Focus on all firm clients, and assure them how they are protected from, not affected by or exposed to, that attorney. If they are (as some will be), take immediate steps to repair the relationship, and work to reinstall confidence.
- Engage in strategic SEO reputation management tactics. News about the bad attorney will keep driving those stories to the top of online searches. Generating more positive news can help counterbalance those negative headlines. Tell a good story. Then tell another one.
- Do good. Pro bono work just makes everyone feel better.
PR as a Reputation Booster
Having good PR strategy and counsel in place is necessary in good times and bad. Unfortunately, too many law firms still don’t believe in the importance of public relations because they don’t understand how a long-term commitment provides direct benefits to the firm.
The impact of PR on reputation occurs in several ways, according to David Rockland, Ketchum’s managing director of Global Research and chair of the International Association for Measurement and Evaluation of Communications.
- It establishes credibility.
- It increases the likelihood that the buyer will purchase services or goods.
- It increases customer/client satisfaction.
- It enhances referrals.
Before one of your lawyers gets into trouble and you know the fallout will harm the firm’s reputation, make sure you have a plan in place. Need help with that strategy? Give me, Vivian Hood, a call at 904-220-1915 or email me at vhood@jaffepr.com.